Silencing Gilfoyle is an outrageous injustice

After 18 years behind bars, found guilty of a murder he has always maintained he did not commit, Eddie Gilfoyle has been allowed out of prison on parole. However, he has only been allowed out on condition that he does not comment on the case.

Last year, police investigation notes that the Merseyside force had always maintained did not exist, were uncovered. They showed that the doctor who declared Mrs Gilfoyle dead told police that she had died six hours earlier – when her hospital porter husband was at work. Paula Gilfoyle had been discovered dead by hanging and there was a suicide note. The police detectives working on the case argued that Gilfoyle had tricked his wife into writing the suicide note, convinced her to put a noose around her neck and climb a step ladder, and then pushed her to her death.

The information that the time of death coincided with Eddie Gilfoyle being at work was withheld from the jury and never mentioned during his trial. Clearly they would have cast reasonable doubt on his guilt. So they were conveniently left out, which is a travesty of justice.

But the injustice continues with this news that the Parole Board made it a condition of Gilfoyle’s parole licence that he must not comment to the media, either himself or via a third party. Who the hell do these people think they are? Presumably they will argue this is for Gilfoyle’s own good, but you can be certain their motives will be entirely selfish. No one must have their freedom of speech curtailed in this way.

There are safeguards under the law to deal with incitement to violence or slander. It is perfectly proper that there should be. But there is absolutely no justification to silence a man, whose conviction was demonstrably unsafe, from speaking about it. It is an outrageous injustice, a wrongful infrigement of liberty and an example of the censorious nature of bureaucrats in this supposed democracy.

Justice must be done but it must also be seen to be done. But increasingly we are seeing people prevented to telling their story in order to protect the establishment from scrutiny and embarrassment. There is this current instance and there are many instances, as Christopher Booker keeps highlighting, such as families that have been ripped apart as their children have been taken from them in kangaroo court hearings who are similarly gagged from speaking about their cases to suit the interests of the authorities.

This enforced silence is utterly wrong. The right of free people to speak to whomsoever they wish must be protected under the law. But instead the law is being used as a cudgel against the people rather than a protection for them. There is something rotten about a country whose officials abuse the law in order to withdraw the rights of others to suit their own ends or hide their failings. The self serving parasites who seek to operate with impuntiy in this way must be stopped if the people of this country are to be genuinely free.

4 Responses to “Silencing Gilfoyle is an outrageous injustice”


  1. 1 WitteringsfromWitney 23/12/2010 at 4:38 pm

    In respect of your last paragraph, AM, one has to ask just what will it take before the people of this country take to the streets?

    I can but repeat the heading to my last post: A nation of sheep breeds a government of wolves.

    And I for one am getting a tad annoyed at the ‘sheepiness’ of my fellow man!

  2. 2 Ian 24/12/2010 at 8:05 am

    Their comment that this would prevent him reoffending further sounds like a nonsense? how would talking to the press make him consider murdering someone else?? it just seems that the authorities by imposing this bad are attempting to hide something.

  3. 3 JohnRS 24/12/2010 at 10:03 am

    Unless its to do with the safety of others (i.e. troops in the field, not the egos of politicians and seat-warmers generally) then the State should have no method of silencing comment or criticism. Any time they do it’s a sure sign that something is rotten with them or their system.


  1. 1 Tweets that mention Silencing Gilfoyle is an outrageous injustice « Autonomous Mind -- Topsy.com Trackback on 24/12/2010 at 11:29 am
Comments are currently closed.



Enter your email address below

The Harrogate Agenda Explained

Email AM

Bloggers for an Independent UK

AM on Twitter

Error: Please make sure the Twitter account is public.

STOR Scandal

Autonomous Mind Archive