Fine Gael’s win will change nothing in Ireland

Ireland’s voters have moved the deck chairs around and the faces in the government ministries will now change. But little else.

Fine Gael will be the largest party in the Dail and form yet another coalition, and Enda Kenny is almost certain to be the new taoiseach. But beyond that, what difference will Ireland’s voters see?

There is excited talk of Kenny starting the process of renegotiating the previous government’s 85bn-euro (£72bn) EU/IMF loan package.  It is something that has echoes of David Cameron’s pledge to renegotiate the repatriation of power from Brussels to Westminster and is likely to have the same outcome.

But then, what else do the Irish expect?  Fine Gael actually helped Brian Cowen’s sinking government to put the Finance Bill to a vote in the Dail, supported some of its provisions and failed to stop the ones it opposed from passing. It is unrealistic in the extreme of Fine Gael to give the impression they will be able to change the terms of the expensive loan the EU and IMF put together.

Bar some tinkering around the edges nothing will change.  Ireland’s voters will still be paying higher taxes and experiencing huge cuts in spending on public services.  They voted for change but will not see any, because when all is said and done the government of Ireland is cannot be found in the Dail, it resides in Brussels.  No one was able to vote for or against it.

Those making the decisions for Ireland have not appeared on any ballot paper. Ireland is not mistress in her own house. The democratic process engaged in by 70% of those eligible to vote is meaningless, a charade, an illusion. How can Ireland’s government be on a collision course with the EU, when the EU is Ireland’s government? It is already making this clear:

As Irish voters headed for the polling booths on Friday, the European Commission bluntly declared that the terms of the EU-IMF bailout “must be applied” whatever the will of Ireland’s people or regardless of any change of government.

“It’s an agreement between the EU and the Republic of Ireland, it’s not an agreement between an institution and a particular government,” said a Brussels spokesman.

A European diplomat, from a large eurozone country, told The Sunday Telegraph that “the more the Irish make a big deal about renegotiation in public, the more attitudes will harden”.

“It is not even take it or leave it. It’s done. Ireland’s only role in this now is to implement the programme agreed with the EU, IMF and European Central Bank. Irish voters are not a party in this process, whatever they have been told,” said the diplomat.

It will become apparent to the Irish people in the weeks and months that despite the campaigning, the voting and the time consuming counting they have changed precisely nothing, they are not a party in this process. It has been nothing more than a very expensive piece of theatre.

The question that will then need to be asked is what will the Irish people do about it.  Will they confirm their surrender, or will they again satisfy their hunger for independence?

5 Responses to “Fine Gael’s win will change nothing in Ireland”


  1. 1 Agincourt 27/02/2011 at 5:24 am

    The 59 year-old ex-teacher Enda Kelly is unlikely to have the political skills or specialist finance & economics knowledge to out-flank the EU & ECB. All he can do is to play for time, & keep saying “No”, or “We must think about it” – while avoiding as many decisions as are harmful to Ireland as possible. A difficult task indeed.

    What might help, however, & concentrate both Irish & EU minds would be to re-introduce a ‘new Irish punt’ – probably after a referendum, & initially at par with the euro. This would give him & Ireland room to manouevre against the EU (i bet closely watched by Greece & Portugal also) – followed by a sudden & unexpected default, if necessary. In the short run, those still holding euros would profit if the new punt devalued against the euro. But a law could be passed converting all euro debts into punt debts at par. Banks & international businesses would be horrified. But ordinary Irish people would look on him as their financial saviour! The EU would hate it! But who cares what those post-democratic bureaucrats think?

  2. 2 jameshigham 27/02/2011 at 10:34 am

    Completely right – the people are not in the driving seat here and shuffling the deckchairs is not going to change the drivers of this mess.

  3. 3 Derek Reynolds 27/02/2011 at 11:37 am

    The people have boarded a different bus.
    None are driving it, and none have yet found the bell to ring it to a stop.
    If they did, who would be the first to ring it?
    And would the driver take any notice?

    As buses – Parties – no longer server the people, as voting has no effect, we need some sugar in the fuel – rebellion.

  4. 4 Uncle Badger 27/02/2011 at 1:05 pm

    Why does this sound so awfully familiar?

  5. 5 Dave Hensley 28/02/2011 at 11:34 pm

    Because Iceland did it, short term pain, long term gain. The sovereign debt was a sham anyway !!!


Comments are currently closed.



Enter your email address below

The Harrogate Agenda Explained

Email AM

Bloggers for an Independent UK

AM on Twitter

Error: Twitter did not respond. Please wait a few minutes and refresh this page.

STOR Scandal

Autonomous Mind Archive